The Americas North America

Witch's Brew

Name: Witch's Brew
Prep time: 15 min
Yield: 12
Cuisine: The Americas
Ingredients: 9 large marshmallows; 18 purple and green candy-coated fruit chews (such as Skittles); 4 cups limeade; 4 (12-ounce) cans ginger beer; 1 L club soda; 1/2 cup fresh lime juice; 2 qt. lime sherbet

Halloween Punch, Spooky Lime Punch, Green Party Punch

Difficulty: Easy
Servings: 12
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Make Time: 0 minutes
Calories: 280 / serving
Diet: Vegetarian

The essentials, at a glance

The Americas Drink - Non-Alcoholic Halloween

This vibrant green punch is a playful and refreshing beverage designed for festive gatherings. Its bubbly texture and creamy sherbet topping create a visually striking effect. The addition of candy-coated eyeballs makes it a perfect thematic centrepiece for Halloween celebrations.

ProteinProtein 4.0g

FatFat 6.0g

CarbsCarbs 52.0g

Above values do not change with any serving size changes you make below

Ingredients

Servings: 12

9 large marshmallows

18 purple and green candy-coated fruit chews (such as Skittles)

4 cups limeade

4 (12-ounce cans ginger beer

1 L soda water

1/2 cup fresh lime juice

2 qt lime sherbet

Ingredients at a glance

Adjust quantities to your preferred serving size.
We only show images for ingredients already in our database.
All drinks depicted are for visual purposes only and should be assumed non-alcoholic unless explicitly labelled otherwise.

Instructions

Cut the marshmallows in half crosswise.

Press one candy into the cut side of each marshmallow half to create eyeballs and set them aside.

Combine the limeade, ginger beer, club soda, and lime juice in a large punch bowl.

Scoop the lime sherbet into the punch and gently stir until the mixture is bubbly and foamy.

Float some marshmallow eyeballs in the punch and place the remaining eyeballs in a small bowl for serving.

Nutritional Benefits

Provides a quick source of energy from carbohydrates.

Lime juice offers a small amount of Vitamin C.

Ginger beer contains ginger which can aid digestion for some.

Hydration is provided by the club soda and limeade base.

Nutritional information is provided as a general guide only. Values may vary and should not replace professional medical or dietary advice.

Recipe Credit

thepioneerwoman.comThe Pioneer Woman's Witch's Brew Punch Is the Spookiest Halloween DrinkIt's made with ginger beer, lime sherbet, and eerie marshmallow eyeballs!

A Spooky Cauldron of Flavour

Andrew T. 1 Nov 2026

From the Blog

All Contributions

Witch's Brew · Andrew T.

Lime sherbet creates a thick, frothy foam that perfectly mimics a bubbling cauldron when stirred into a punch bowl. This technique transforms a simple mix of ginger beer and club soda into a visually striking treat that is as fun to look at as it is to drink.

The sharp tang of fresh lime juice cuts through the sweetness of the limeade, ensuring the drink remains refreshing rather than cloying. Adding the marshmallow eyeballs provides a whimsical, slightly eerie touch that always gets a laugh from guests.

Perfect for Parties

I love how this drink brings a bit of theatrical flair to the table without requiring any complex cooking skills. It is a fantastic way to add a bit of colour and excitement to a festive gathering, making it a real crowd-pleaser for all ages.

Yum Feedback

0 comments

Food, Place & the Past

Yumpedia: North America

The tradition of the party punch in North America dates back to the 17th century, though the modern "themed" punch is a more recent evolution of American social hosting. During the mid-20th century, the rise of convenience foods and pre-made mixers like limeade and ginger beer allowed home cooks to create large-batch drinks for community gatherings and holiday parties.

The specific concept of a "Witch's Brew" emerged from the cultural desire to create immersive environments during Halloween. By combining bright, unnatural colours-often achieved through lime-flavoured ingredients-with whimsical garnishes, the drink transforms from a simple beverage into a piece of edible decor. This reflects a broader trend in American party planning where the visual "wow factor" is as important as the taste.

Continue reading in Yumpedia